How wood rot affects a New England house, and how to check for it

What rot is, where to look for it on your house, how to test it yourself, and when it's more than a trim problem.

Close-up of peeling white paint and rotted wood on the underside of exterior roof trim

Wood rot is a fungus eating your house, and it only grows where wood stays wet. That one fact explains almost everything about it: where it shows up, why it comes back, and why a repair that doesn't stop the water won't last.

Here's what to look for on your own house and how to tell a small fix from a big one.

What rot actually is

Rot is caused by fungi that feed on the fibers in wood. Their spores are everywhere, in the air and on every board on your house. They can't do anything to dry wood. Once wood stays damp for long stretches, the fungi start breaking it down, and the wood loses its strength from the inside out.

That's why rot shows up in the same kinds of places over and over. Anywhere water sits, soaks in or can't dry out is a candidate. A New England house gets plenty of that: rain and snow, freeze and thaw opening up joints, and humid summers that keep shaded wood from drying.

"Dry rot" isn't dry

People call crumbly, cracked, brown wood "dry rot," and it does look dry by the time you see it. But the fungus needed moisture to do that damage. It's either still getting water from somewhere, or it was wet for a long time and has since dried out.

This matters because the name sends people looking in the wrong direction. If you think dry rot happens without water, you'll replace the board and skip the question that counts: where is the water coming from? Find that, and you've found the reason the rot is there.

Where rot hides on New England houses

Rot starts where water collects or gets trapped, which means it's usually at the bottom of something or behind it. The spots we check first:

  • Fascia and the trim under the roof edge, especially behind gutters that overflow or where ice dams back water up under the shingles.
  • The bottom corners of window and door trim, plus window sills and door thresholds.
  • The bottom rows of siding and corner boards, where snow piles up against the house all winter.
  • Anywhere a roof meets a wall, like a porch roof or a dormer, if the flashing is missing or failing.
  • Deck boards, stair treads and the tops of posts, plus the board that attaches the deck to the house.
  • Porch columns, especially at the base where they sit on the floor.

The photo with this post is a typical case: trim under a roof edge where paint kept peeling, until the wood underneath opened up.

How to test for rot with a screwdriver

You don't need special tools. Take a flat screwdriver or an awl and press the tip into the wood with firm hand pressure, about as hard as you'd push a thumbtack.

Sound wood resists. The tip barely goes in, and when you pry, it lifts out a long splinter. Rotted wood gives. The tip sinks in easily, sometimes all the way to the handle, and when you pry, the wood breaks off in short, crumbly pieces with no grain to it.

Test the lowest point of each piece first, like the bottom of a window casing or the end grain of a deck board, since that's where water sits. Then work up until the wood feels solid again. That gives you a rough idea of how far it goes. Don't stab every board on the house. A few gentle probes in the right spots tell you what you need.

Push on any spot where the paint keeps peeling year after year. Paint won't stick to wood that's staying wet, so a spot that won't hold paint is often a spot with rot or water behind it.

Cosmetic rot vs structural rot

Most rot people find is in trim, siding, fascia or deck boards. That's cosmetic, in the sense that the house isn't relying on it to stand up. It still needs fixing, because rotted trim lets water get behind it to the framing. But it's a manageable repair.

Structural rot is different. These are the parts that carry weight:

  • Sill plates, the boards that sit on top of the foundation and hold up the walls.
  • Rim joists, which run around the edge of the floor framing.
  • Deck ledgers, the board that bolts the deck to the house. When a ledger rots, the bolts lose their grip and the deck can pull away from the house.
  • Deck and porch posts, beams and joists.
  • Wall framing behind a long-term leak.

Signs of structural rot include a floor that feels soft or bouncy near an exterior wall, a deck that sways or has gaps opening where it meets the house, or rot you can see in the basement along the top of the foundation. If you find any of those, get it looked at soon. This kind of damage doesn't stay put.

Why catching it early keeps the repair small

Rot spreads as long as the wood stays wet. A soft corner on a window casing this year can be the whole casing next year, then the sill, then the framing under the window. Each step means more wood to remove, more parts to match and more of the wall to open up.

Caught early, a rot repair can be one piece of trim. Left alone for a few seasons, the same leak can turn into sill and framing work. Small repairs are worth a call.

How a repair that lasts gets done

A good rot repair has three parts, and skipping any one of them means you'll see the same spot again.

First, remove all the bad wood. That means cutting back until there's nothing but sound wood left, which is often farther than the visible damage. Rot spreads inside a board before it shows on the surface, and we always check behind the piece we can see, since the sheathing or framing behind a rotted trim board is often wet too.

Second, replace it with something that holds up better. For trim that gets a lot of weather, that can mean PVC trim like Azek, or a rot-resistant wood, primed on every side including the cut ends before it goes up. For structural parts, it means pressure-treated lumber where it touches concrete or sits near the ground.

Third, fix how the water got in, and make sure it has a way out. The fix can be new flashing, a drip edge, a gutter fix, re-caulking, or adjusting the grade so snow and rain drain away from the house. This is the step that keeps you from calling about the same spot next year.

You can read more about how we handle it on our wood rot repair page, and rotted deck boards, stairs and posts are part of our deck repair work. If you've found soft wood on your house, call or text us at 781-248-5017 and we'll come check how far it goes.

Free estimate

Tell us what you're building.

We'll get back to you to set up a time to see the job. Estimates are free.

Based in
Windham, NH
Serving
Southern NH and Northern MA

Request a free estimate

It takes about a minute.

Rather talk? Call 781-248-5017.

Thanks. We've got it.

We'll be in touch soon to set up a time.

Call now Free estimate